The Short Answer

Most of the money a business loses on visibility goes to an agency that promised a ranking or a place in the ChatGPT answer, delivered neither, and left the website worse off. The signs are checkable before you pay. Google's own hiring guide says no one can guarantee a first-place ranking, and OpenAI's help page says advertisers cannot alter ChatGPT's answers, so a guarantee of either is the first sign. The others: they contacted you first, the numbers in the proposal have no source, their own site names nobody, the method is stuffing or bought links, they will not list the changes, they want full access on day one, and there is no report you can open yourself.

Short on time? Ask an AI to summarise this post:

A message arrives on WhatsApp. "We noticed your business is not showing on Google or ChatGPT. We can fix that in 30 days, guaranteed." The price is reasonable, the owner is busy, and the website has been a nagging worry for a year. The money leaves quietly over the next few months. The business ends the year as invisible as it started, and sometimes less visible, because part of what was sold is what Google calls spam.

This post lists nine signs that the agency in front of you cannot deliver what it is promising. Most of them are in Google's own words, from the page it publishes for owners who are thinking of hiring help with search and from its spam policies. One comes from OpenAI's help page on ads. None needs technical knowledge to check.

We are an agency. Read every sign against us too, and the FAQ says how.

Why owners get sold the wrong thing

Constant Contact and Ascend2 surveyed more than 1,300 small-business decision-makers in February 2024 and found that 73% lacked confidence in their marketing and 56% had an hour or less a day for it. BrightLocal's SMB Marketing Report 2025, a survey of 778 owners, found that 54% run their marketing entirely alone. An owner who doubts their own marketing, has no time for it, and has nobody to ask is the easiest customer in the world for a guarantee.

Two people's hands across an office desk, one holding a printed proposal and a pen out for signing, the other holding a pen, with a laptop open behind them
Photo by AymaneJed on Pixabay

The seller knows this. The pitch is built for an owner who wants the worry to go away and cannot check the claims. So the defence is a short list of claims you can check in ten minutes, before any money moves.

Google's page for owners hiring search help was last updated on 5 June 2026, and its spam policies page on 28 August 2026. Both are linked in the references, and the quotes below are taken from them on 25 October 2026.

Sign 1: They guarantee a ranking, or a place in the AI answer

Google's hiring guide says it in one line: "No one can guarantee a #1 ranking on Google." It goes further: "If they guarantee you that their changes will give you first place in search results, find someone else."

The same is true of AI answers, and more so. As of 25 October 2026, OpenAI's help page on ads in ChatGPT says "advertisers have no ability to shape, rank, or alter ChatGPT's responses." If the companies paying OpenAI for ads cannot buy a place inside the answer, an agency in Lagos, London or Houston cannot sell you one. A guarantee of being named by ChatGPT is a guarantee the seller has no way to keep.

What a legitimate proposal says instead: here are the changes we will make, here is how we will measure the result, and the engines decide the rest.

Sign 2: They found you, you did not find them

Google's guide tells owners to be wary of agencies that "email you out of the blue". In Lagos the email is a WhatsApp message or an Instagram DM, often with a screenshot of your website "failing" a scan. The scan is generic. It produces the same red marks for every site it is pointed at, and the message was sent to a hundred businesses that morning.

An unsolicited message is the cheapest way to sell, and the cheapest way to sell attracts the cheapest work. Some good agencies do reach out, so the test is specific: ask the sender to name one thing wrong with your site that would not be wrong with the shop next door. A real answer names your page, your phone number, your service. A template cannot.

Sign 3: They claim a special relationship with Google, or an approved tool

Google's guide warns about agencies that "allege a 'special relationship' with Google" and about tools that claim to be "acceptable" or "approved" by Google Search. Google publishes the same documentation to everyone and certifies nobody to rank you. The same goes for OpenAI and Perplexity: their crawler pages, linked below, describe how their systems read the web, and neither names any partner who can get a business into an answer.

When this claim appears in a pitch, it is there to stop you asking how the work is done. Ask anyway.

Sign 4: The numbers in the proposal have no source

A proposal deck says that a round percentage of searches now end without a click, or that AI will replace Google by some year, or that businesses using the agency's method see traffic rise by some multiple. Ask three questions about each number: who measured it, how many people did they ask, and when?

A real figure carries its source in the same sentence. Pew Research Center surveyed 5,119 US adults in February 2026 and found that 49% use AI chatbots, up from 33% in 2024. That is what a sourced number looks like: the organisation, the sample, the date, the figure. A proposal whose numbers cannot be traced is a proposal whose results will not be traceable either, because the habit is the same.

Sign 5: Their own website names nobody

An agency that sells you visibility to machines should be visible to them. Open the agency's website and look for a named founder, a street address, a phone number that matches their Google Business Profile, and a named author on their articles. Then ask ChatGPT and Google what they know about the agency, by name.

If the machines cannot say who the agency is, the agency has not done to itself what it is proposing to do to you. If the agency's site has no person on it at all, you are being asked to trust a logo. The engines will not, and neither should you.

Sign 6: The method is stuffing pages, buying links, or building hundreds of pages

This is the sign that costs the most, because the damage outlasts the contract. Google's spam policies page defines keyword stuffing as "filling a web page with keywords or numbers in an attempt to manipulate rankings in Google Search results", link spam as "creating links to or from a site primarily for the purpose of manipulating search rankings", and scaled content abuse as "when many pages are generated for the primary purpose of manipulating search rankings". The same page states the consequence: "Sites that violate our policies may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all."

The hiring guide adds the sentence every owner should read twice: "Ultimately, you are responsible for the actions of any companies you hire." Google penalises the website, which is yours. The agency's contract will have ended.

So if the plan is two hundred pages for two hundred areas, or five hundred backlinks by the end of the month, or a service page where the same phrase appears in every sentence, the plan is to get your site demoted with your money. For AI answers the position is the same. Google's guide to its generative AI features says that seeking inauthentic "mentions" across the web "isn't as helpful as it might seem". Placed mentions are not the consensus the engines are looking for. Real reviews and real answers are.

Sign 7: They will not say what they will actually do

Google's guide: "Be careful if a company is secretive or won't clearly explain what they intend to do." One of the questions it tells owners to ask is "Will you share with me all the changes you make to my site".

The honest work is boring and can be listed. Rewrite the service page so the first paragraph answers the question a customer would ask. Make the business name, address and phone number identical on the website, the Business Profile and every directory. Check that the crawlers are allowed in. Collect real reviews. Ask the same five customer questions every month and write down who is named. Every item on that list can be shown to you before and after.

A method that is "proprietary" and cannot be described is a method you cannot check was done. Ask for the list of changes before you pay, and for the list of changes made after each month.

Sign 8: They want full access on day one

Google's guide says to grant an agency read access to Search Console at the start and "don't grant them write access", and that an agency with access to your server "should be willing to explain all the changes".

The owner's version is simpler. Your domain registration, your hosting, your Google Business Profile and your Search Console stay in your name and in your account. You add the agency as a user. You can remove them in a minute. An agency that insists on registering the domain itself, or on moving the site to hosting only it controls, or on becoming the owner of the Business Profile, is building a lock. When the relationship ends, the website ends with it.

Sign 9: There is no measurement you can check without them

Google's guide tells owners to ask: "What kind of results do you expect to see, and in what timeframe? How do you measure your success?" The answer should point at a report you can open yourself, in an account you own.

Three such reports exist and all are free. Search Console, in your own account, shows clicks and impressions, and since 31 August 2026 Google's blog says every site has a Generative AI performance report there showing appearances in AI Overviews and AI Mode. Bing Webmaster Tools has an AI Performance report, in public preview since 10 February 2026 according to Bing's own announcement, showing which of your pages Copilot and Bing's AI answers cite. And the plainest one: a fixed list of five questions a customer would ask, put to ChatGPT on the same day each month, with the businesses it names written in a sheet.

If the only evidence of progress is a dashboard on the agency's own website showing a "visibility score" nobody else can reproduce, you are paying for the dashboard. On the timeframe part of Google's question, be suspicious of a confident answer. OpenAI, Google and Perplexity publish no figure for how quickly a new or changed page is picked up, and an agency that names a date is guessing.

What the right agency does instead

Google's guide describes the other kind. The right agency, it says, "should ask questions about what makes your business unique", and "if they're not interested, find someone who is". The first meeting is about your customers: what they ask on WhatsApp before they buy, what they get wrong about you, which question you wish they would stop asking because the answer is on the website nobody reads.

Then the proposal lists changes, names the report you will read, keeps every account in your name, and refuses to guarantee what nobody can. Google also says to "check business references" and to ask past clients whether the service was useful. Do that. Two phone calls cost nothing.

Here is what the customers you are both trying to reach are doing, from sources you can check:

49%
US adults who use AI chatbots, up from 33% in 2024
Pew Research Center, Americans and AI 2026
45%
US consumers who used AI for local business recommendations in the past year, up from 6%
BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2026
54%
US small-business owners who run their marketing entirely alone
BrightLocal, SMB Marketing Report 2025

The customers are asking the machines. The question is whether the agency you pay can make you the business the machines name, and whether you will be able to see it happen without taking their word for it.

Want to know where you stand before anyone sells you anything?

Our free AI Visibility checklist is the 12-point check we run before we quote. It starts with what ChatGPT, Gemini and Google say when a customer asks about a business like yours. Enter your email and we will send it over.

✓ Check your inbox, your checklist is on the way!

We respect your privacy. Unsubscribe at any time.

Key Takeaway

Nobody can sell you a ranking or a place inside an AI answer, and Google and OpenAI both say so in writing. Pay for the work you can see listed, measured in an account you own, by people who put their own names on their own website.

One forward before you go: before you sign anything, ask the agency two questions in writing: which changes will you make to my site, and which report, in my own account, will show whether it worked? Keep the answers. If either question gets a vague reply, you have your answer.

Frequently asked questions

Is AI visibility just SEO with a new name?

The work overlaps with good SEO, and an agency that says so is being honest. The difference is in what gets measured. SEO reports rankings and clicks. AI visibility measures whether your business is named, and described correctly, when a customer asks ChatGPT, Gemini or Google's AI Mode a question. Google's own guide to its AI features says the work is still SEO; no SEO dashboard reports the ChatGPT answer, so that part has to be measured separately.

Can an agency guarantee that ChatGPT will recommend my business?

No. OpenAI's help page on ads, as of 25 October 2026, says advertisers have no ability to shape, rank, or alter ChatGPT's responses. If the people paying OpenAI cannot buy a place in the answer, an agency cannot either. What an agency can do is the work that makes a business findable, readable and confirmed elsewhere, and then measure monthly whether the name appears. That is labour, and it is worth paying for. A guarantee is not.

What should I ask an agency before I pay?

Google's hiring guide suggests the questions. What results do you expect, in what timeframe, and how do you measure success? Will you share every change you make to my site? Can you show previous work and references? Add two of your own: which report in my own account will show the result, and what happens to my website if we part ways? Write the answers down and compare them across two proposals.

What access should I give an agency?

Add them as a user to accounts you own; never hand over the account. Google's guide says to grant read access to Search Console at the start and not write access. Your domain registration, your hosting, your Google Business Profile and your Search Console should stay in your name, with the agency added and removable. If the agency insists on owning any of these, that is the sign.

How do I check the work myself, without the agency's dashboard?

Three places, all free. Search Console in your own account shows clicks, impressions and, since 31 August 2026, a Generative AI performance report for AI Overviews and AI Mode. Bing Webmaster Tools has an AI Performance report in public preview showing which of your pages Copilot and Bing's AI answers cite. And a fixed list of five customer questions, asked to ChatGPT on the same day each month with the named businesses written down, tells you whether you are being named.

Does this apply to Nexum-sol too?

Yes, and you should run every sign against us. Our founder's name and our Lagos address are on this site, our method is published in plain words, our audit lists the changes before anyone pays for them, and our reporting is the monthly question run plus your own Search Console. We do not guarantee a ranking or a mention, because nobody honestly can.

How long should it take before I see results?

Nobody can give you a date. OpenAI, Google and Perplexity publish no figure for how quickly a new or changed page is picked up. A good agency says so and sets a measurement date instead: the same questions, the same engines, the same day next month. An agency that names a week is guessing, and one that names a day is selling.

References & sources

  1. Google Search Central, Do you need an SEO? (Google's guide to hiring search help) (read 25 October 2026; last updated 5 June 2026. Source of the guarantee, out-of-the-blue, special relationship, secrecy, access and questions-to-ask quotes)
  2. Google Search Central, Spam policies for Google web search (read 25 October 2026; last updated 28 August 2026. Keyword stuffing, link spam and scaled content abuse definitions; consequence sentence)
  3. Google Search Central, Guide to optimizing for generative AI features on Google Search (last updated 10 July 2026; the inauthentic mentions sentence)
  4. Google Search Central, AI features and your website (eligibility, no special requirements)
  5. Google Search Central blog, Introducing Search Generative AI performance reports in Search Console (announced 3 June 2026; all sites from 31 August 2026)
  6. OpenAI Help Center, Ads in ChatGPT (read 25 October 2026: advertisers have no ability to shape, rank, or alter ChatGPT's responses)
  7. OpenAI, OpenAI bots documentation (OAI-SearchBot, GPTBot, ChatGPT-User)
  8. Microsoft Bing Webmaster blog, Introducing AI Performance in Bing Webmaster Tools Public Preview (10 February 2026)
  9. Constant Contact / Ascend2, Small business marketing survey, February 2024 (1,300+ SMB decision-makers; cited by name)
  10. BrightLocal, SMB Marketing Report 2025 (778 owners; cited by name)
  11. BrightLocal, Local Consumer Review Survey 2026 (1,002 US adults)
  12. Pew Research Center, Americans and AI 2026 (5,119 US adults, February 2026)
A
Abdulmuiz Adebowale
AI Product Manager & Builder, Nexum-sol

Abdulmuiz helps Nigerian businesses build websites and digital systems that get found, by people and by AI. He writes about practical SEO, AI search, and growth systems for SMEs at Nexum-sol.